Identifying the issues as viewed by older residents in cities
The challenge
By 2030, sixty per cent of the global population will be living in cities, with at least a quarter of city dwellers aged sixty or over. Clearly the needs and requirements of this age group will become an increasingly significant aspect of social and public policy, both in terms of design and delivery. And whilst progress has been made in identifying key age-friendly interventions, older people have rarely been central to their development. Moreover, how people’s experience of old age in Greater Manchester can be vastly different. The city has one of the lowest life expectancy rates in the United Kingdom, and this varies across different geographical areas. Being older can be an opportunity for some people but for others it can be more of a challenge, for example those living in neighbourhoods with high poverty rates, crime levels and low investment in public services.
Our research
This was a project led by Tine Buffel and Chris Phillipson, and funded through an EU Marie Curie Intra-European Fellowship. It builds on work already being conducted in the city of Manchester which focuses on the experiences of social exclusion and inclusion among ageing populations. The aim of the research was to identify the issues older residents themselves viewed as important in developing the age-friendliness of their neighbourhood. A further aim was to involve older people, not only as the research target group, but also as experts and actors in the planning, design, development and implementation of the study.
A diverse group of eighteen older residents (aged between 58 and 74) were trained as co-investigators. They conducted sixty eight interviews across South Manchester with older people who were experiencing social exclusion, isolation, poverty or health problems. The interviews focused on ways of improving the quality of life for older people living in urban communities. During the training sessions, attention was given to the design of the research, to ensure that it was particularly sensitive to marginalised voices within the community.
The study found that many people’s quality of life was reduced by their susceptibility to multiple forms of exclusion (poverty, social isolation, loneliness and the experience of crime). However, the research also found that older people retained a strong commitment to neighbourhoods in which they had lived for most of their lives.
‘The good thing about this project is that the co-researchers are older people who live in the community themselves. If you live in the area you are more likely to know people who don’t go to meetings and who are not active in the community. The elderly people feel more comfortable talking to you than to researchers. They know you understand the issues’ (Male co-researcher, 60)
The impact
As a result of the research, important principles have been established in terms of promoting age-friendly neighbourhoods:
- First, the neighbourhoods must provide a mechanism for empowering older people and ensuring broad social participation.
- Second, they are a reminder of the importance of ‘citizen rights’ in terms of ensuring full and active use of a city’s resources and services.
- Third, they affirm the importance of recognising the multi-layered nature of the urban environment, where social and physical constraints affect the lives of older people in a variety of ways.
Taken as a whole, the Manchester Ageing Study represents a significant advance in research methodology and in developing new models of community engagement. Crucially, it contributes to re-thinking public policy in relation to age-friendly cities, drawing on the direct involvement of older people themselves.
The work carried out in Manchester has received various accolades, including winning the ‘Outstanding Local Community Collaboration Award’ at the 2015 University of Manchester Social Responsibility Awards. The work has also attracted interest from both the WHO – pioneers of the age-friendly cities agenda – and a number of key UK and European policy actors.
