Case Study: The rights of undocumented migrants

Case study banner

Gaining an understanding of status and experiences of undocumented migrants

The challenge

The issue of migration is never far from the political headlines in the United Kingdom and is highly contested. The Immigration Act 2014 enacted by the coalition government presents undocumented migrants as criminals and has increased enforcement measures against them. However, not all undocumented migrants have entered the UK without legal permission and instead this may have expired or been altered by a change in circumstance.

A key challenge is this hostile political environment leaves undocumented migrants vulnerable to crime and exploitation, since they have restrictions to access to healthcare, housing and employment. A further challenge is the decision making process about the status of migrants, which is often experienced as unfair and unjust. Altogether there is a lack of research informed evidence about how the system is experienced and how it could be changed to work better.

Our research

With funding from the Economic and Social Research Council, a team of researchers from the University of Manchester have collaborated with the Migrants Rights Network holding a number of consultation meetings with local stakeholders to gain the migrant perspective on the nature and effectiveness of the system. This included Manchester-based migrant community organisations, migrants, local government workers, legal professionals, and researchers with relevant expertise and research interests.

The findings revealed that the current policy focus is often experienced by local stakeholders as unjust and not capable for making the most arbitrary of decisions. For example, many undocumented migrants applied for asylum before becoming undocumented, and questions were raised about the transparency of the system. This lead to the recommendation that a reform of the asylum system is needed to ensure that decision making is fair and that people are not becoming undocumented unjustly.

‘Dr Lewis has interviewed some of the leading exponents in the U.K., reviewed studies from across Europe and spent a significant amount of time with our customers in order to develop this guide. We have learned a massive amount along our journey that will help us deliver similar exciting projects in the future. I hope that this guide will enable and inspire others to take on similar projects and to continue advance the development of low energy homes in the UK.’ 

Dave Williams / Group Director of Assets and Growth, One Manchester

The impact

A policy briefing document has been produced which outlines the recommendations of the research. This has been sent to a number of MPs and civil servants which ensures the research is feeding into public policy debates. A number of presentations have been made around this and a policy blog and infographic have been created which help ensure the research is impacting on actors across a range of levels. Various events have also been organised across Greater Manchester more specifically to engage the findings of the research with local stakeholders, for example including the recent ‘Migrants in Manchester’ touring exhibition. 

Discover more