Case Study: Inequalities in school choice for migrant parents

Case study banner

The impact of race, gender and class

The challenge

Greater Manchester is often considered as one of the most diverse cities outside of London. The population has grown in recent years, and much of this growth can be attributed to increased migration. For example, Greater Manchester has a higher proportion of Asian and Black African or Black Caribbean residents than other parts of England and Wales. A key challenge for migrants with young children is how to negotiate the United Kingdom education system with very little pre-existing knowledge and information about this including social networks to obtain this information. However, we know that migrants are a diverse group demographically and this raises questions of how issues of race, ethnicity, gender and class shape differences in the barriers they face when negotiating schools and school choice within our region.

Our research

This was an Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) funded project on migrants, school choice and the impact of race, ethnicity and class. We conducted 47 semi-structured interviews with individuals as well as group interviews with 54 participants. This included a combination of migrant and non-migrant parents and all were from the Greater Manchester area.

The findings highlighted examples how race, ethnicity, gender and class shape different barriers for migrant parents over schooling. For example, many migrant women did not feel confident asserting their children’s rights in public institutions, and were often marginalised from decision making by male relatives.

In addition, many migrant parents described wanting their children to go to ethnically diverse schools but faced a tension between sending them to schools with ‘too many like us’ (as a form of resistance to racialized categories) and schools with not enough ‘like us’ (out of fear of potential racism).

Our research therefore demonstrates the impact of race, ethnicity, gender and class on migrant parents choices over schooling, and how they negotiate these in order to avoid social disadvantages that the ‘wrong choice’ might have on their children.

‘I think [schools] are quite scary for a lot of parents that maybe have led an isolated life or maybe they have a language barrier, or even if they don’t have a language barrier, they’re born even in this country, maybe they just don’t have the confidence or they’re not aware of how it works. . . . That is the only – these are the main things that stop them from questioning.’

Outreach worker / Bangladeshi women’s organisation in central Manchester

The impact

The research has an important impact for people living in Greater Manchester because it demonstrates the inequalities faced by migrant parents over school choice and the impact of race, ethnicity, gender and class.

It has implications for policy makers at a local and national level because it suggests not only that such inequalities need to be addressed but may also require different strategies that recognise the diverse nature of inequalities faced by different migrants living in the UK.

Our research findings have formed the basis of a number of presentations aimed at academic and policy audiences in the UK including a keynote symposium at the British Educational Research Association. The findings are also presented on a website which disseminates the outputs to academics, policy makers and individuals on the issue of school choice, schools and inequalities.

Discover more