Case Study: The educational equity toolkit

Case study banner

The challenge

It is known that poverty is associated with poor educational attainment. Technical responses to this have over a number of decades included performance management, data gathering, a marketplace of school choices, and more vocational options on the school curriculum. And yet there is little evidence of improved educational equity. The challenge is that such technical responses ignore wider influences such as public spending cuts and students’ own values. How can urban schools reflect on and improve their efforts to tackle educational inequity effectively?

Our research

Professor Carlo Raffo has formulated an Education Equity Framework that complements aspects of the work of the Chicago Consortium (Bryk et al., 2010) who found that multiple simultaneous efforts by schools with their communities best addressed systemic influences on education inequity. He then developed this framework into a value-driven Education Equity Toolkit designed to analyse education inequity by questioning educational practice at the micro, meso and macro level - three analytical tiers developed by researchers within Manchester Institute of Education’s Disadvantage and Poverty thematic programme of research and presented in the 2010 Joseph Rowntree Report Education and poverty, a critical review of theory, policy and practice. The toolkit is designed to be a resource for a non- technical response to educational injustice – it prioritises ideas associated with relational equity.

  • At a micro level the Education Equity Toolkit asks questions about individual experience within the classroom and within the school.
  • At a meso level the toolkit looks at the relationships of families, communities and neighbourhood locales to educational inequity.
  • At a macro level the toolkit looks at national or global impacts, such as austerity, on educational inequity.

 Our research underpinning the toolkit suggests that there is a need for a shift in the axes of educational power from national and local policy makers and professional practitioners to community-based fora where elements of teaching and learning in schools could be co-constructed and co-produced with community representatives, families and young people.

Professor Raffo has studied Manchester Communication Academy as an authentic example of professionals, organisations, young people, families and communities attempting to work together in equitable ways to make things educationally better and fairer in their communities. He analysed its process using the toolkit and found it to be a successful and pioneering project on two of the three tiers. The challenges of schools, from a local level, attempting  to influence the macro level remains an open question for educationalists and policy makers, since we found that without broad systemic changes root causes of educational inequality would not be addressed. 

Discover more