Reconsidering participation in the higher fees era
The challenge
At a national level, there is a challenge for young people of any background to understand and negotiate a new fee and repayment structure for English Higher Education (HE), and to reach appropriate decisions about whether to participate based on a full understanding of all the relevant information. This challenge is particularly acute in some areas of Greater Manchester because participation rates in HE are historically low.
Our research
Our research speaks directly to those most affected by higher fees in English Higher Education: young people attending low participation schools and from families where participation is relatively unusual. Our research sought to understand more about how students’ financial considerations interacted with other views, attitudes and dispositions they had towards university. Our research focused on high-attaining young people who were from lower socio-economic backgrounds. We know young people from these backgrounds are less likely to progress to high-prestige universities and we asked them how the prospect of taking on greater student debt affected their decision-making process.
We have to understand better how young people think about and talk about university if we are to maximise opportunity and minimise inequality – the language of policymakers and the media doesn’t reflect the decision-making process of all would-be students.
Steven Jones
The impact
Together with other studies, for example a Sutton Trust report by the Manchester Institute of Education looking at how some applicants could be disadvantaged by the university application process, our research aims to impact not only on national Higher Education policy, but also on the outreach work undertaken by universities across England. In areas of inequality, such as Greater Manchester, access is limited not only to direct educational resources, such as private tuition and attainment-driven schooling, but also to less visible forms of capital, such as help from family members and access to ‘insider’ knowledge. Our findings show that, almost as important as the ‘attainment gap’, is a ‘wherewithal gap’. Many students have the ability to secure a place at a high-prestige university but struggle to grasp issues around student finance and university selection processes. The lessons of the research point to a need for more nuanced, context-sensitive approaches to widening participation, and our recommendations include simplifying application processes and financial support systems.
Discover more
- Times Higher Education, 19/12/13: “‘Bursary’ means nothing to disadvantaged pupils”
- Sutton Trust, 7/12/12: “The Personal Statement: a fair way to assess university applicants?”
- BBC News interview, 7/12/12 “University personal statements ‘further disadvantage’ poor”
