Is Britain really becoming more divided?
The challenge
Debates on racial diversity and segregation across the UK, including Greater Manchester, have up to now been dominated by myths. Discussion has been largely reactive to events, for example surrounding racial tensions or the rise of far right politics, rather than being informed by evidence.
Our research
Our research provides a key resource for non-governmental agencies, political parties and the wider policy community involved in the production of evidence-based policy. In particular, it presents policymakers with alternative, better-informed evidence on ethnic diversity and its effects within the UK. It challenges the current focus on simply managing the negative influence of cultural diversity and immigration.
More specifically, our work addresses ethnic segregation and local ethnic group population change in areas such as Greater Manchester. We have generated innovative methods for estimating neighbourhood ethnic group population change. We are currently analysing census and survey data in order to provide a direct and critical challenge to widespread myths about segregation and diversity.
Manchester has some of the most ethnically mixed neighbourhoods in the country, and they are characterised by diversity rather than segregation. Myths about increasing segregation are a distraction from the many positives of diverse neighbourhoods in Manchester, and from action to address more significant issues of inequalities.
Dr Nissa Finney / University of Manchester
The impact
Our research has provoked debate and challenged established views. It offers local authorities and other non-governmental organisations a more informed understanding of race, segregation and diversity. Through an explicit strategy of ‘myth busting’, we have also informed and shaped policy debate within government, improved public understanding of segregation and transformed thinking around ethnic and neighbourhood diversity.
Many common assumptions about race, migration and segregation are myths. For example, we found that Greater Manchester has become increasingly diverse over the last two decades, whilst at the same time residential segregation has decreased. Indeed, the proportion of people living in multiple ethnic group households has increased in all districts in Greater Manchester. Eight out of ten of the most diverse wards in the Greater Manchester region are in Manchester. Within these wards ethnic minority groups have grown, but they also live in more ethnically mixed residential areas. Despite this increase in ethnic diversity Manchester is not becoming less British.
We also identified that natural change (the difference between births and deaths) is the main driver of local population change for many areas and ethnic groups.
The evidence base we have generated shapes the practices of prominent race equality organisations, such as the Runnymede Trust, in campaigns promoting alternative frameworks for understanding race, segregation and migration. Our work continues to challenge public concerns regarding integration.
Discover more
- Centre on Dynamics of Ethnicity (CoDE)
- Ethnic Mixing in Manchester, CoDE briefing paper
- Geographies of Diversity in Manchester, CoDE briefing paper
- Area Profilers (CoDE)
- Is Britain becoming more segregated? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z89p2uM56Xg
