Case Study: ‘Nudging’ citizens

Nudging citizens

What makes people give time and money to good causes?

The challenge

Across the UK, including Greater Manchester, citizens have to make hard choices about whether to give their time and money for various social initiatives and causes. We consider how positive reinforcement and indirect suggestion, known as nudge theory, might encourage informed decision-making and promote positive civic behaviour.

Our research

We ran eight ‘real world’ experiments in Greater Manchester, and elsewhere, to show whether people would donate goods, money or their time if they received the right messages. 

The project used a variety of techniques to test the most effective ways citizens could be encouraged to develop positive civic behaviours such as making charitable donations, recycling waste or volunteering their time for community groups.

Such research is valuable in that it gives direction to activities and ensures valuable resources are not spent on activities that are not effective

Director / Community HEART

The impact

Our research raised charitable donations and improved recycling rates within Greater Manchester. It led to recommendations on how to ‘nudge’ citizens towards positive civic behaviours. These have subsequently informed government policy at the local and national levels. 

Firstly, as a result of our experiments 1,000 Manchester households donated 7,000 second hand books to children’s libraries in South Africa, through the charity Community HEART. This was fostered through a pledge-drive, alongside a public recognition of individual efforts. Secondly, a 5% increase in recycling rates was recorded following door-to-door canvassing of over 6,500 households in Old Trafford. Thirdly, feedback cards delivered to more than 9,000 homes in Oldham increased participation in food waste recycling by 6%. Fourthly, participation in an online debate on antisocial youth behaviour and interracial relationships produced marked improvements in tolerance. Our research shows that as well as incentive based ‘nudges’ to change behaviour, citizens also wanted opportunities to think and reflect upon key social problems before taking action.  

Many organisations in the UK already have a strong interest in using nudges.  Several, including central and local government, have used our research as part of their assessment of whether and how to deploy such techniques. 

A further series of experiments, around whether information about other peoples’ donations of time affect the willingness to give time themselves, are currently underway. 

Discover more