Addressing the multiple inequalities faced by children in deprived areas of Greater Manchester
The challenge
Manchester has a higher than average child poverty rate compared to the UK average. This is a particular issue in geographical pockets of the region including North and East Manchester. It is well known that children from disadvantaged socio-economic backgrounds fare less well in terms of their outcomes. For example, they are more likely to become involved in criminality and have poorer health and employment outcomes than those from more privileged backgrounds. Evidence from Manchester confirms this and there are clear health, education and employment inequalities that become more apparent in the most deprived geographical pockets of our region. However, the relationship between socio-economic disadvantage and outcomes is inherently complex. The issue for policymakers is that standalone initiatives are not enough to tackle this and multi-strand approaches are more effective.
Our research
We have worked in partnership with Save the Children (an international children’s charity) to put forward ‘children’s communities’ as a way of addressing socio-economic disadvantage for children living in deprived areas of England. Children’s communities include a partnership between various organisations and agencies in the community (e.g. schools, health services and local government) to ensure the ‘right mix’ of initiatives are used to tackle the specific inequalities facing children in the local community.
Recent developments include a partnership with Save the Children to set up four pilot initiatives across England including two in Greater Manchester. Our responsibility has been for the long term evaluation of these activities and we have employed a ‘theory of change’ approach. This requires the careful planning of the outcomes with the community partners from the outset, and then decisions are made about the mix of interventions that will be required to achieve these.
An example of one of these pilot initiatives is a children’s community set up in Collyhurst in Greater Manchester which is characterised by high rates of unemployment, a loss of a sense of pride in the area and isolation of residents from opportunities in other areas of the city. As such, community partners decided on a strategy to change the image of the area and to instil a sense of pride among young people and residents. An extensive publicity campaign was run which highlighted the positive aspects of living in the area.
Although at an early stage in the evaluation process, initial findings lend tentative support for the impact of children’s communities on socio-economic disadvantage. However, tensions and ambiguities have been identified and the evaluation process has allowed for these to be addressed as they unfold.
‘Implementation of the strategy has the potential to make a real and measurable difference for children, particularly in some of England’s most disadvantaged communities. We know the need is great, and increasing. English children’s zones could make a significant contribution to meeting that need.’
Naomi Eisenstadt / Trustee, Save the Children
The impact
The findings of the research formed a report for Save the Children (an international children’s charity) which will impact on people, organisations and agencies with an interest in socio-economic disadvantage for children and ways to address this. There has also been an authored book reviewing the history of and evidence for area based initiatives and developing a theoretical and practical model to inform their future development.
