Case Study: Coming Clean

Coming Clean

Identifying better procurement and employment practices for subcontracted cleaners

The challenge

In common with trends across the UK, many organisations across Greater Manchester procure cleaning services from specialist contractors. All too often, however, contracting practices focus on cost-cutting with adverse consequences for low-wage, subcontracted cleaners. The challenge for our research was to identify more responsible procurement practices that would improve working conditions for cleaning operatives and raise awareness of employment rights.

Our research

Greater Manchester faces a challenge of how to grow jobs of decent quality to support improved living standards for the local population. During this period of slow recovery from a major recession many jobs involve irregular hours, low pay and insecurity; women in part-time jobs are especially vulnerable. Improving standards of employment in the commercial cleaning sector, a sector well-known for its poor working conditions, would therefore send a welcome signal to other low-wage sectors of the economy and hopefully have positive ripple effects. Our research included case studies of banks, NHS trusts, city councils, airports, hotels and educational establishments in different regions of the UK, including Greater Manchester. The cases were designed to explore key features of procurement and contracting arrangements and to highlight ‘better practices’ for employment conditions. 

Our recommendations [to the key bodies in the cleaning industry] focus on the most significant findings, and address the need to: improve working conditions for cleaning operatives; raise awareness of employment rights; and establish more responsible procurement practices.

Equality and Human Rights Commission quoting University of Manchester research

The impact

Our research has several important lessons for people, organisations and policy makers in Greater Manchester.

  • Compliance with TUPE rules (to protect terms and conditions of employment of cleaning staff moving from one organisation to another)
  • Raising the baseline unit price to enable payment of higher rates of basic pay
  • Time and resources to facilitate cleaners’ collective representation. 
  • ‘License to practice’ requirements
  • Minimum training provision specified in tenders
  • Avoidance of very short contracts
  • Greater focus on workers’ needs for working-time security and stability over cost considerations
  • Stopping the practice of zero-hours contracts
  • Enforcing enhanced pay rates for unsocial hours working.

These recommendations have already fed into discussions at Manchester City Council on how to incorporate a living wage in their supply chain, as well as to improving practices at the case-study organisations that participated in our research. The lessons also have more general application to other low-wage contracted services, such as catering and security services, across Greater Manchester. Better procurement practices can significantly enhance job quality for many thousands of people living in the region.

Discover more