Recession, austerity policy and labour market inequalities
The challenge
The 2007 economic recession had severe implications on the United Kingdom (UK) labour market including increased rates of unemployment and a decline in real wages. However, these implications were more pronounced in Greater Manchester than at the national level, and the recovery was much slower. The UK government responded through implementation of a number of austerity measures including cuts to public services and welfare reform which has reduced both in-work and out-of-work benefits. These changes have intensified pressure for benefit claimants to seek and accept any type of work and this is reinforced by more frequent benefits sanctions, and this might help explain the rise in part time and non-standard forms of employment since the recession. However, austerity policies by their very nature restrict the available support for people to stay in and move into employment, so the question is what are the implications of this? And how might some groups be more negatively impacted on than others? And if so, in what ways?
Our research
This was a Marie Curie funded project on the effect of organisations and institutions on individual’s labour market and life-course options, and compared across the contexts of both the UK and Spain. It included some secondary data analysis to identify employment transitions over the course of the recession and subsequent austerity policies, and this was supplemented by fifteen interviews - 11 of these were carried out in Greater Manchester.
The findings revealed how the recession and austerity policies impacted on young people and women more than other groups. For example the findings demonstrated how austerity policies restricted women’s ability to find new employment or enter retraining, meaning often their only option was to rely on family. This presents a clear danger in terms of social inequality because it means support for women’s transitions may be contingent on household and family resources thereby meaning many women are trapped in low incomes.
‘I get [child] tax credits but they have been cut from about £50 a week to £15 or so….on a normal basis I am paying £65 per week for childcare as it is for the afternoon, but during summer holidays is £22 per day, is not enough…So I am now working on the weekends too… but I have to pay the childcare for the weekends as well then…yes, they are helping [the older kids] but they will go to university next year...'
Women, 43 yo, social worker, 3 children / affected by wage cut
The impact
The research impacts on organisations and policy makers because it provides insight into the effect of the recession and austerity policies, and suggests the need to rethink how we approach employment regulation and public policy. In particular, it suggests the need to develop innovative institutional and organisational level policies to support (not restrict) individuals at times of recession to enable them to reorient themselves in a changing context.
Whilst much policy making is done at the national level, devolution may present an opportunity to rethink some of these aspects, for example the Work Programme which supports people into employment is being devolved and there is the potential for more devolution in the future.
A radical argument might be for devolution of certain aspects of employment regulation although this would require lobbying to national government and may be complex in terms of law. The findings have been presented to an audience of academics and policy makers at a range of national and international conferences, and a special one-day workshop was held by the University of Manchester’s on European Work and Employment Research Centre (EWERC) on ‘Labour market chances and transitions in times of austerity with an audience of 57.
