Case Study: Improving employment outcomes for ethnic minority groups

Case study banner

Improving employment outcomes for ethnic minority groups

The challenge

Greater Manchester is an ethnically diverse city, and has a higher number of black and minority ethnic groups than many other UK cities. However, this brings about challenges in the labour market because we know ethnic minority groups often disproportionately discrimination and barriers to employment compared to white and British born people. Yet there is a lack of knowledge about how Britain’s ethnic minorities experience such disadvantages – clearly this is a diverse group and the question is how these barriers take shape in different ways. In particular, we know that women and people from deprived areas often suffer the most barriers to employment so the question is how this impacts on people from different ethnic minority groups too.

 Our research

This research project was funded by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, and led by Ken Clark and Stephen Drinkwater. The aim was to examine the diverse experiences of Britain’s ethnic minorities, and to provide a detailed understanding of to what extent there are ethnic differences in labour market outcomes, and in particular by both ethnic group and gender as well as across the paid and self-employed sectors. It drew on Census data from 1991 and 2001 as well as the Labour Force Survey.

The findings revealed that, whilst some groups improved their labour market position relative to white people, substantial disadvantage remains for most both in terms of access to jobs and earnings once in employment. It should also be noted that ethnic disadvantage was gendered in ways that reflected cultural differences between groups. For example, the employment rates of Pakistani and Bangladeshi women were particularly low (less than thirty per cent) and this was potentially explained by cultural attitudes towards labour force participation and childcare. In addition, whilst we know that living in a deprived area has a negative impact on employment outcomes, this was found to be much greater for Britain’s ethnic minority groups. The implications of these findings are that public policy may require different strategies for tackling the diverse labour market disadvantages for ethnic minorities, and we identify some of these in our report for the Joseph Rowntree Foundation.

'Without the work of the IDeA guide which informed the ‘Unlocking the Potential of the BME Population’, this demographic group may not have been featured in RS2010 or Future North West.  Having read this report, along with a multitude of other strategic inputs, meant I was careful to explicitly specify ethnic minority groups as an important part of the overall imperative for the region to create more employment opportunities and raise employment rates.' 

Tracy Mawson / Director of Business Services St Helens Chamber

The impact

The research has fed into a report for the Joseph Rowntree Foundation on ‘Ethnic Minorities in the Labour Market: Dynamics and Diversity’. This informs a number of strategies that seek to address gaps in ethnic minority employment, for example a spotlight was placed upon the importance of equipping under-employed groups with the skills required to access employment opportunities.

Following the report, the research has fed into an evidence base informing policy at the Department for Work and Pensions and numerous local authorities, and helped to shape the 2010 regional economic strategy of the North West Development Agency. The report and associated work was featured in the press, notably The Economist, and on radio and television, including the BBC Radio 4 Today programme and the Channel 4 ‘Dispatches’ series.

On the back of this positive coverage, Clark and Drinkwater were approached by the UK Government’s Department of Work and Pensions and the Local Government Innovation and Development Agency (IDeA) to write a ‘how-to guide’ for economic development officers at local authorities, which would assist them in crafting evidence based policy responses to the increases in ethnic minority unemployment, triggered by the recession. From late 2009 to early 2010 the guide was promoted at a series of regional workshops (for Regional Improvement and Efficiency Partnerships), reaching a total of 439 delegates.

Discover more