Case Study: Young people and the barriers they face progressing through education or employment

Case study banner

Young people in inner city Manchester and the barriers they face in progressing through education, training or employment

The challenge

Research from the Joseph Rowntree Foundation  indicates that educational differences start very young and widen. Factors identified as potentially contributing towards what is often called the attainment gap include the aspirations, attitudes and behaviour of parents and children which the research believes can play an important part in explaining why poor children typically do worse at school. By 16 and older, it is considerable.

  • Tests at age 3 show a significant gap between more affluent children and the poorest fifth
  • Lower-achieving but more affluent children overtake the highest low-income achievers by age 7
  • Poorer children are half as likely to go to university as their more affluent peers

Such educational differences are known to impact on young people’s ability to access the key further education, employment and training opportunities that serve as gatekeepers to the route out of poverty. Over the past few years young people have seen the removal of the Education Maintenance Allowance, cuts to advice and support services (particularly locally based youth services), a reduction in further education funding and the removal of entitlement to a series of welfare benefits. For a review of these changes see the Guardian. According to the Princes Trust (2014) nearly one million young people are not in employment, education or training and 430,000 young people face long term unemployment.  With the school attainment gap seemingly resistant to change and both the employment market and post 16 education sector being severely squeezed we wanted to talk to the young people directly experiencing these forces to find out what barriers they are facing in Moss Side/Hulme/Old Trafford as they negotiate the journey from school into work, training or further education.

Our research

With funding from the Just GM research programme we undertook focus group research with 14- 19 year olds in Moss Side and Hulme on the barriers they face in progressing through education, employment or training. We met with young people at two local youth projects, Hideaway and the Powerhouse, and ran two focus groups supported by the local youth workers.

From the two group discussions we gathered a wide range of data focused primarily on the barriers the young people were experiencing in progressing through or into education, employment or training. It is the barriers that they were experiencing and their thoughts and feelings concerning these that in actuality dominated much of the focus group discussion for both groups. Much of the discussion was located for the young people in a ‘us’ and ‘them’ frame, with the ‘them’ being other young people who didn’t live in inner city Manchester and had money, transport, access to jobs, networks and contacts that the focus group participants didn’t have. The main barriers were identified as poor Guidance and Advice, Stereotyping and Racism, Lack of Money and Lack of Workplace Experience. Two further strong themes to emerge from the research were personal, social and emotional issues and relationships.

Personal, social and emotional issues

This theme was connected to the young people’s own inner experiences which was a consistent topic of conversation. All of the group were openly self-reflective and used the language of the social and emotional learning (SEL) discourse so recently dominant in the English school’s curriculum (Humphrey, 2013, Watson and Emery, 2012). The key factors in this theme were lack of self-confidence and self-assurance, negative thinking, low personal opinion of self, lack of personal motivation and anxiety regarding their vision of the future.

Relationships

The influence of relationships (family and friends) was a strong focus for the group with many of the participants reflecting on this and identifying both the positive influences and the negative influences. Family were in general seen as a supportive positive factor however the role of friends was a much more complex one with many in the group relating stories of negative influence and friends being a barrier to them moving forward. The young people related a wide range of informal relationship networks that were key to them successfully navigating the barriers they faced.

Discover more