The living wage in UK local government
The challenge
Since the economic collapse of 2007-08, the living wage has become a symbolic issue of pay equity and social justice across the UK, including areas such as Greater Manchester. The gap between pay rates and the hourly wage required to achieve a basic standard of living is increasing, and worryingly this pattern is now beginning to spread to unionised sectors such as local government.
Our research
Our findings used publicly available data on living wage agreements in UK local government and our own case study research, funded as part of a CASE studentship by the ESRC and the UK’s largest public sector union UNISON.
The living wage is calculated on an annual basis based on typical housing and living costs. It is estimated that over 5 million UK workers earn less than the living wage, and workers in sectors such as cleaning, retail and hospitality are particularly at risk of low wages. There is no statutory underpinning to the living wage: employers can implement a policy locally without accreditation with the Living Wage Foundation, and there are no mechanisms by which the accreditation obligations can be enforced. In October 2014 there were over 800 employers accredited, and although a number of Greater Manchester authorities are working towards a full living wage, at present Salford City Council is the only one to be fully accredited.
For some of them it’s had a tremendous impact in their life. One council cleaner was very emotionally moved because we had tried to help and it had a real impact...I think what we’ve done is good but it makes me realise how far we have to go because it’s still not a high wage
Local Authority Leader / Greater Manchester
The impact
Despite high levels of unionisation and collective bargaining coverage, around half a million local authority workers earn less than the living wage. Raising pay rates at the bottom would benefit large numbers of part-time women working in areas such as cleaning, school catering and social care.
Over 100 councils claim to be living wage employers, but not all living wage policies are created equal:
- Where a full living wage is not affordable, or councils do not want to make a long-term commitment to higher rates of pay, they may implement a temporary or non-consolidated version of the living wage (which can later be withdrawn or adjusted).
- Many councils who are working towards a full living wage such as Oldham are not yet accredited: this means they are not obliged to honour the annual uplift and can maintain control over pay increases in the future.
- Even those councils who have achieved accreditation have struggled to insert living wage clauses into contracts with private providers. The legal risk and additional costs associated with changes to the procurement process are often cited as key barriers.
The recently introduced Social Value Act for public sector procurement offers some room to include clauses which relate to employment standards, but it seems likely that the extension of living wages to external staff will be an increasingly important issue for many councils.
More broadly, our research has shown that at a time when public sector funding is being significantly reduced, efforts to raise starting rates may come up against other policies designed to reduce workforce costs such as cuts to jobs and hours, outsourcing, and changes to terms and conditions. Trade unions tend to be broadly supportive of living wages, but local branches have to remain vigilant to prevent better wages for one group of staff being paid for by cuts elsewhere.
Discover more
- 2013 Living Wage Research for KPMG: Structural Analysis of Hourly Wages and Current Trends in Household Finances
- European Work and Employment Research Centre
Mathew Johnson is studying a PhD on People Management and Organisations, Manchester Business School, The University of Manchester
