Case Study: The Work Programme

Case study banner

The challenge

Greater Manchester is envisaged as central to the Northern Powerhouse vision of economic development, but there are entrenched problems in some parts of GM, for instance high structural unemployment; low skill levels; and employment barriers such as disabilities and offending behaviour. The Work Programme was started in 2011 by the Conservative-Liberal government to improve ‘welfare to work’ services by contracting them out to large firms such as G4S, Avanta and A4e at an estimated cost of £1.2 billion per annum.

We wanted to know how well The Work Programme is performing in Greater Manchester: does it meet the diverse and sometimes complex needs of participants, particularly in the region’s poorest areas?

Our research

Our researchers found that in GM the Work Programme offered significant inequalities of experience among different groups of unemployed people, depending on postcode, age, gender, disability and other characteristics of vulnerability. In Bury and Wigan the performance for placing a referred client in a job within 12 months improved by just 50% from 2011 to 2014 while in Stockport it improved by 180%.

Combining original analysis of secondary data from the DWP (Department for Work and Pensions) and the ONS (Office for National Statistics) with interviews with Work Programme participants and staff, and others, Mat Johnson (European Work and Employment Research Centre) and Damian Grimshaw (Manchester Business School) discovered some fundamental problems with the Work Programme although it was working well with certain portions of the population.

Our researchers’ also found perverse incentives operating with The Work Programme:  payments to contractors were bigger for those with more complex needs, incentivising the  ‘parking’  of these individuals while targeting others identified as ‘closer’ to the labour market and able to make a quicker transition to a job. This ‘creaming’ of referrals drove up success rates, as measured by work achieved and sustained, since ‘work ready’ clients require less support.

Our research highlighted discrepancies between the ‘walk’ and the ‘talk’ of the jobs market ; GM has made tentative steps towards becoming a high-skill, high-wage economy but a large proportion of jobs created since 2010 have been in the low-wage retail and hospitality sectors, with limited opportunities to progress and insufficient opportunities for the rising number of graduates.

Participants in the Work Programme felt they were pushed to take jobs too soon with detrimental consequences if the position was then not held. Job Clubs, whose funding is now more precarious and whose role in the support of those seeking work has been much diminished, provided a richer and more flexible source of support. Jobs Club provision could in fact provide a model for a more responsive approach to job seekers’ disparate needs.

Johnson and Grimshaw make the case for new investment to deliver tailored and flexible programmes of skills training and confidence building. Their analysis suggest problems with the ‘one size fits all’ application of ‘work first’ principle.

Discover more